Issue Theme: Shyness & Temperament.
|
| |
Talking to Teachers about Our Shy Child
We have an unusually sensitive child who has presented
many difficulties and home, but few in public, although
his extreme fussiness as an infant and extreme shyness
as a preschooler were apparent to outsiders in the early
years. Because of David's (not his real name) poor adaptability
and shyness, we were always apprehensive when trying to
introduce him to group situations, from play groups to
primary school.
He also had a very short attention span and difficulty
following instructions and expressing himself, making
social and school situations even harder for him. People
thought his attentional problems were related to social
anxiety, but they were apparent at home, too, where he
was far from shy, and in fact, was a very oppositional,
negative child, who expressed his frustration and reactions
to stress most often with me, his mother.
Our problem in introducing our child to the world of
education was whether to say to the teachers that our
son was 'difficult' when the main difficulties -- in the
commonly understood sense of inappropriate, so-called
'bad' behavior -- occurred only at home. We certainly
didn't want teachers to develop any apprehensions about
his behavior, with his self-esteem already in jeopardy.
Besides, we were sure he would be well-behaved (although
maybe sometimes confused and stressed) at school.
Although, especially in the early years, I desperately
wanted to tell teachers how 'difficult' David was, perhaps
to get some support from them, I decided not to use this
actual term in discussions with them. But the problem
remained: exactly what should we say to them?
Then I heard a child psychiatrist at a talk say that
teachers should not try to diagnose children in discussions
with parents but should only describe what specifically
the children are doing that is causing concern. For example,
the teachers should say: "He has difficulty paying
attention for long" rather than "I think your
child has attention deficit disorder". Or they should
say: "Your child isn't interacting much with the
other children" rather than "Your child is anxious".
After hearing this, I thought to myself that this might
be a good rule for me to follow when discussing David
with teachers, since a screening exam had found nothing
unusual about David that a teacher needed to know. One
mildly abnormal EEG is not useful information for teachers,
whereas knowing that another child actually has epilepsy
would be. So I decided only to describe David as a whole
person when talking to teachers. This included emphasizing
his high intelligence, gentleness with other children,
and fun-loving nature, as well as mentioning his slowness
to adapt to new situations, his need for positive attention
even when he seemed to shun it, and his tendency to get
confused easily.
I also developed a routine of saying to the teachers
how much David up to school (true) even though he was
so shy and, at first, uninvolved. (In play groups, through
kindergarten, he was a bystander, just watching the other
children and doing his own playing.) I emphasized how
much David liked school because I thought that maybe teachers
would like him if they knew he liked them in their programs.
I also didn't want them to feel that they were failures
as teachers because they couldn't make him as shy or more
adaptable. I knew only too well what it felt like to be
a failure at making a child more like other children.
I explains that much of David's behavior was related to
his temperament, and that both a child psychologist and
pediatrician had said this. I explained that he had been
born sensitive and that we were a shy family. Because
I knew that they would offer alternative theories, I always
acknowledged the role of his allergies and family stress
in his sensitivity. (I didn't bother to point out that
he, being such an allergic and fussy baby, had caused
most of the stress!) I also asked for their suggestions
on ways we could help David at home. I figured they must
know something about children. I found that when I approached
teachers this way, they were very willing to understand.
Of course, a parent doesn't just want a teacher to understand
her child's difficulties, but needs the teacher to be
an ally in helping the child overcome any serious adjustment
problems. One thing I did to help this along was to ask
the teacher to let me know if she observed any budding
friendships occurring between David and the other children,
so I could invite those other children over. I knew that
going to school with a buddy that he also saw outside
of school would help greatly.
Teachers have been quick to pick up my suggestion to
use humor, even tickling, to help David relax at school
and to give him the attention that other children get
by asking for it or acting out.
I know my story doesn't offer much to parents whose children
are likely, for reasons related to their temperaments,
to misbehave at school. In a way, your situation is much
harder, and I wish you luck!
|